I was shocked that anything (besides gold) managed to lose ground Tuesday, until I saw what it was. Then I wasn’t surprised at all. Literally, every single sector and every single industry was up on the heels of Tuesday’s rally, except one…. educational services. In other words, the for-profit schools industry was a solo loser.
What’s up with that? It is a little weird, if you don’t know the back-story. If you think about it logically though, it actually makes sense.
Did you know that the S&P Educational Service Index gained 115% between March of 2008 and January of 2009? Say WHAT? It’s true. Think about it. What do people who get laid off (and can’t get rehired) do when they have plenty of time but not enough qualifications? Right...they go back to school. That’s why these stocks became more compelling as the economy - and unemployment - worsened. (continued below)
Therefore, what would be the most detrimental to for-profit schools? Right again… a strong (well, strengthening) economy. The market seems to think so anyway.
Normally I wouldn’t jump on board the ‘obvious logic’ wagon train, as ‘obvious’ is also frequently ‘wrong’. However, I also uncovered this looming weakness before Tuesday.
I routinely scan all the major stocks using a system that’s designed to highlight the very best bearish and bullish opportunities. Care to guess what showed up on my bearish list a couple of weeks ago? Apollo Group (APOL), Corinthian Colleges (COCO), ITT Educational (ESI), Devry (DV), and a few other lesser-known educational names.
Now, if it had just been one or two out of the group showing up on the bearish list, I may have thought nothing of it. But, when I start seeing the majority of an industry telling me to at least get out of these stocks - if not telling me to get outright bearish - I listen. I may not trust people or ‘obvious logic’, but I sure trust my system. Why? My system never lied to me. It may be wrong sometimes, but it doesn’t lie about my odds.
The point is, I’m taking Tuesday’s hint at face value. Educational stocks are probably not where you want to be right now. You may even want to take on bearish trades in these stocks.
I know, I know…. the unemployment trend is still on the rise, which should theoretically push more students into these schools, not out of them.
However, stocks also trade about six months in the future. And let’s face it - the economy has to get better sometime; the stimulus is going to take hold sometime too. Will that be six months from now? Sounds about right, which also means unemployment - and therefore school enrollment - will also start to slide soon. That’s exactly why I think these stocks are headed lower now. It ain’t an errant move or a blip.
Here are a few more relevant charts. It’s pretty amazing how all the hints are there, if we just learn to take ‘em.
Do you want the early notices about the beginning and end of industry trends well before anybody else spots them? Sign up for the newsletter today, and you won’t miss another big money-making tip.